Jump to content
Sony Insider Forums
Lute

Advise on the best recording MD device needed. Thanks!

Rate this topic

Recommended Posts

Dear Community,

 

Some 12 years ago being still a conservatory student, I owed a sony MD player as many of us did. Then somehow I put it away.....

Recently after having recorded some Cds with regular digital equipment I started to seriously doubt concerning the end result and realized that my old midi life recordings have some musical aspects which I totally miss on cds. I definitely cannot explain this in terms of physics...... I decided to buy a reel to reel band machine for studio registration and return to MD for portable concert session recordings.

Those two formats have something at the end which is not about resolution and quality of sound -  it is about music itself. It is quite obvious to me.

So I would like to kindly ask for advise - which MD recorder you find appropriate and probably best for this, since as far as I know the ATRAC format made some advances after MZ - R70 which I had. Thanks a lot for attention and time reading this. Anton

www.luteduo.com

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you do your own field recordings with the unit, I advise you to choose a Hi-MD for these reasons

 

1) quality of recording (even lossless with PCM)

2) lengh of the recording if you get Hi-MD discs (but classic MD formatted in Hi-MD mode offer also a rather long lengh of recording if you don't choose the lossless quality)

3) possibilty of upload of your own recordings even in WAV format : <<Self-Recording Upload Function Hi-MD Walkman recorders offer two-way communication from the PC to device and from the device back to the PC. With the mic in feature5 you can make a self-recording on the device and transfer content back to the PC.>> technical short extract of the MZ-RH900. Nota : Sony has stated that only analog-source recordings created on Hi-MD equipment will be eligible for upload.

 

The Sony MZ-RH1/M200(for Mac) is the best (and most expensive) but others Hi-MD recordings units allow also the upload of your own field recordings. See the minidisc.org browser for units and the FAQ.

 

Price range : Rh1 > 200 to 800US$ (!), others recording Hi-MD units 50 to 250US$, Hi-MD blank discs much more than 10US$ nowadays (just format classic MDs in Hi-MD mode to save money.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would like to propose an alternative, based on my own experience. I own two Sony MZ-RH1's, as well as two HHB MDP500's. I definitely prefer the HHB for field recording, for the following reasons:

1. Robustness: the MDP500 is designed for professional field use ; the MZ-RH1 is very fragile.

2. Connectors: the MDP500 has XLR (line and mic) inputs ; the MZ-RH1 has a mini-jack.

3. Ergonomy: the MDP500 has large keys and display ; the MZ-RH1 has tiny buttons and display.

4. Connectivity: the MDP500 uploads via plain USB Audio ; the MZ-RH1 requires specific Sony Software.

5. Autonomy: the MDP500 uses standard batteries ; the MZ-RH1 uses specific Sony gumstick batteries.

6. Resilience: the MDP500 uses MD's that can be recovered after a crash ; Hi-MD's cannot be restored.

7. Price: a second-hand MDP500 can be bought for less than 200 euros (typically on on www.ebay.co.uk).

In short, I would recommend the MDP500, connected to the output of your console via balanced XLR's, to record your own performances on stage. And yes, you will have to accept one ATRAC 4.5 compression (during recording), followed by one ATRAC 4.5 decompression (during the real-time upload to the PC).

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dear Friends,

 

Thanks a lot for sucha detailed answer and time spent. I will consider those options. Meanwhile I bought yesterday a  used Pioneer  MJ D707 for almost no money to have it as a stationary unit at home. And made a home recording with it .... It brings already a fantastic result. So I think if I buy the ones you mentioned it will be exactly what is needed. I wonder why this Atrac comression makes such a natural recording so simple? It is still digital but somehow more humane... Is there any clear explanation for this? Thanks a lot for advice ideed! Anton

www.luteduo.com

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For me it reminds me of a cassette recorder, i can record anything anytime, unlike CDs which somehow seems to be very complicated.

I used to record morning radio shows on cassettes, now since i have rh910, i have been using that one instead.

For me, the trade offs between having a solid state player ( flash based ) larger capacity, easy format (mp3) compared to the ability to switch discs and stone age simple recording, track split and editing is very worth it.

I wont be taking my rh910 for 2 week trips, ( my Cowon D2 ) will do that for me, but as my daily player the rh910 makes perfect sense. Record the morning show on MD while showering n getting ready for work, then listen it on my way to office.  30 minutes to 1 hour worth of recording at Hi-SP does it for me. i use regular MD discs. i keep the one i like, and over write the others. wash rinse and repeat :) awesome i say.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


×