soft or silicon case?

[nebs]

hey, im going to be getting a case for my a3000 and im going for either the silicon or the soft one, ive seen pictures of them both and i think the softone looks better but i would have to take it out of the case to use it.

the silicon case looks a bit ugly imo, does it look that bad when in real life than it does in this picture:

i like the idea of the grip on the silicon one (wont fall off the dash or what ever) and also the fact that i can use it while its on but it just looks ugly... lol

so what do you think of both the case?

has anyone got them and would recomend one over the other?

i dont realy like the new plastic ones coming out, they look a bit silly and i dont like the idea of putting hard plastic over the top of my NW

[nebs]

bump

[sh33p]

I think the silicon case is pretty cool and it totally takes the mick out of ipods. Plus it would probably provide the player with the best collision protection. I still think it's a bit silly the screen doesn't get any protection though, but there you have it.