md optical out vs analogue

[denwin]

I have live recordings from a portable md (no optical out) in lp2 and lp4 mode.

I want to do the best transfer to a digital sound studio to edit the tracks.

Would an optical out be much better than using the headphone analogue out for the transfer?

Where can i find an md player with optical out and lp2/4 mode? Or is there a better way for best quality

[denwin]

I know this is basic stuff to experienced users and i have just started reading the forum.

 Mine is an MDLP  model MZ-G750.

it seems there are 3 levels of sound quality

1. analogue via headphones out (i've tried it...ok)

2. optical (i need a deck with optical out and can play lp2/4)

3. best quality digital with usb using MZ-RH1 (probably imperceptible difference)

So optical seems most practical way to go...please advise.....what machines can do this? any available?

[Another MD fanatic]

Hi

I suggest you don't use the analogue output from the MZ-G750 as you won't get a flat frequency response. Sony portables give a small amount of bass boost even with the bass boost switched off. It's only a couple of db but enough to be noticeable. A few years back I did some accurate tests which proved this.

Incidentally Sharp and Panasonic portables however do give a flat response. This in turn gives a slightly clearer mid range but a less warm sound (IMO).

As to what decks have an optical output and are LP compatible I have no idea so somebody else will have to answer that for you.

Cheers

[sfbp]

There are lots of decks with optical out, just make sure you get one with MDLP. anything starting with 4 or 7, some with 6 or 9. Check back with us, or at http://minidisc.org/equipment_browser.html

Alternatively you can buy, rent or borrow an MZ-RH1. If there's only a few MDs, some kind soul might even offer to transcribe (upload) them for you. You cannot improve on that, as LP is uploaded bit-for-bit to a computer.