Jump to content

Can minidisc (ATRAC SP) capture the essence of vinyl?

Rate this topic


netmduser

Recommended Posts

Wow-that soared over my head!

So, how does one find out which labels put out decently sounding cd's? This makes the hunt for quality music that much harder. And now, in the downloaded content era, how does one guarantee that the company you're d/l your tracks from aren't simply applying the same limitations and bad mastering the previous media distributors did?

I think I need a beer now.

"Vinyl releases" - surely you're kidding, now.

Actually, there are a lot of albums coming out these days. Many on 180gram vinyl, 45rpm issues, Non LP style (wider grooves, etc). I pick most of my Gogol Bordello on vinyl.

http://store.acousticsounds.com/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why would the ear even hear the difference between -120 and -121 dB?

Trouble with digitizing is that the presence of even a low level high frequency component makes the signal unsuitable for analog-to-digital conversion. I.e., non-compliant with the requirements of the Nyquist theorem. And noone can predict, which parts of the signal will be affected as a result. The presence of a low level high frequency component may easily affect perfectly hearable sounds.

So, how does one find out which labels put out decently sounding cd's?

Well, the big four certainly do not. And even an indie label is not a guarantee, since the material will usually still be overcompressed and clipped at the factory.

And now, in the downloaded content era, how does one guarantee that the company you're d/l your tracks from aren't simply applying the same limitations and bad mastering the previous media distributors did?

Most downloads are overcompressed and mostly clipped. And don't forget the simple fact that most of them are nothing but CD rips.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...

Can anyone help? I just had a horrible experience with a third-party phono preamp. It's not close to specifications: the channels are mismatched (and it changes as you vary the gain), there is terrible hum, and the sound is basically awful. I compared with the existing sound from my Kenwood, and there's no way I would ever trade in the latter now until I find a replacement.

(To make matters worse the Ebay seller is acting all dishonest and saying that they only accept "defective* returns, hahaha, so yelling and screaming ensued as they claim it's not defective).

The problem arose because I am getting a new receiver that doesn't have phono input. I guess I should have been patient until finding one with all the other things I wanted in a receiver AND phono input too, but I wasn't......

So I need to know if there exists a properly balanced, hum-free, high-quality RIAA-corrected preamp for a moving magnet cartridge for not too much money. Clearly an alternative is to lug the Kenwood, the turntable and one MD deck down to the basement to use until such time as I run out of vinyl to convert.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Can anyone help? I just had a horrible experience with a third-party phono preamp. It's not close to specifications: the channels are mismatched (and it changes as you vary the gain), there is terrible hum, and the sound is basically awful. I compared with the existing sound from my Kenwood, and there's no way I would ever trade in the latter now until I find a replacement.

(To make matters worse the Ebay seller is acting all dishonest and saying that they only accept "defective* returns, hahaha, so yelling and screaming ensued as they claim it's not defective).

The problem arose because I am getting a new receiver that doesn't have phono input. I guess I should have been patient until finding one with all the other things I wanted in a receiver AND phono input too, but I wasn't......

So I need to know if there exists a properly balanced, hum-free, high-quality RIAA-corrected preamp for a moving magnet cartridge for not too much money. Clearly an alternative is to lug the Kenwood, the turntable and one MD deck down to the basement to use until such time as I run out of vinyl to convert.

Is this the one you bought?

http://bit.ly/42HMfr

If not, it might be worth a shot. I was planning on getting it myself.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No, I got something that claims "Its quality easily matches or exceeds that of the phono preamps found built into older stereo components". Load of ***p. No names, I don't want a flame war. PM me for the real details.

I'll give the one you show here serious consideration. Thank you.

Edit: Well my enthusiasm for that didn't last long, the review (Amazon, I am sure you can find it) read like a carbon copy of my complaint to the makers of the other one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Really? So finding a new standalone decent phonopreamp is a hopeless quest then.... There's a guy on ebay selling an NAD PP-2, would that be any good?

Do those NEW units that still have a PP included use decent circuitry or not? One unit I looked at was the Sony STR-DG1000 (and 900 too) but I really haven't much idea whether reading the circuit diagram will tell me anything.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Really? So finding a new standalone decent phonopreamp is a hopeless quest then.... There's a guy on ebay selling an NAD PP-2, would that be any good?

Do those NEW units that still have a PP included use decent circuitry or not? One unit I looked at was the Sony STR-DG1000 (and 900 too) but I really haven't much idea whether reading the circuit diagram will tell me anything.

NAD products have always been a good choice, have you looked through pawn shops etc to see what people may have bought in and forgot about? That would be my first start if I was in an area that had them.

Good luck and happy hunting

Bob

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...