I am a 30 year career professional audio engineer.
I selected the SRS-XB2 after auditioning many other units in a department store that had about 10 different models. I used to have Bose Soundlink 2 but the rediculous amount of bass on the unit annoyed me.
After getting one unit home I decided to order a 2nd one to take advantage of the dual unit stereo mode.
However its instantly apparent that when using 2 units in stereo the L & right signals are reverse phased, leading to cancellation of almost all centralised bass signal and an unatractive sounding mid frequency reproduction
When listenting to pop / rock or dance music productions - the kick drum (bass drum) and bass are typically centrally located in the stereo field or 'panorama'. In a correctly phased stereo set up, bass signal from the left and right speaker combined should be additive (ie centrally panned signals should combine 50/50 to make up 100% volume) you should clearly be able to hear the kick drum in the middle and the bass instruments also.
But listening with your head in between two equally spaced SRS-XB2 units, there is no such low end signal additive combination (it is clearly subtractive or "bass light") and mid frequency signals exhibit the classic 'eriee / 'behind you' sound that an out of phase stereo speaker set up typically gives you.
On a wired speaker set up this would be remedied by swapping the + /- speaker cables on ONE speaker to put them "in phase"
Its a shame that such a cool product suffers from this fundimental problem.
Would the moderators product evangelists here kindly please test this and bring it to the attention of Sony engineers please?
I would like to have a pair of SRS-XB2's that are correctly in phase.
(I suspect the rear facing bass units are the culprits, they may need to be "phase flipped"
Question
alexwaston
Hi
I am a 30 year career professional audio engineer.
I selected the SRS-XB2 after auditioning many other units in a department store that had about 10 different models. I used to have Bose Soundlink 2 but the rediculous amount of bass on the unit annoyed me.
After getting one unit home I decided to order a 2nd one to take advantage of the dual unit stereo mode.
However its instantly apparent that when using 2 units in stereo the L & right signals are reverse phased, leading to cancellation of almost all centralised bass signal and an unatractive sounding mid frequency reproduction
When listenting to pop / rock or dance music productions - the kick drum (bass drum) and bass are typically centrally located in the stereo field or 'panorama'. In a correctly phased stereo set up, bass signal from the left and right speaker combined should be additive (ie centrally panned signals should combine 50/50 to make up 100% volume) you should clearly be able to hear the kick drum in the middle and the bass instruments also.
But listening with your head in between two equally spaced SRS-XB2 units, there is no such low end signal additive combination (it is clearly subtractive or "bass light") and mid frequency signals exhibit the classic 'eriee / 'behind you' sound that an out of phase stereo speaker set up typically gives you.
On a wired speaker set up this would be remedied by swapping the + /- speaker cables on ONE speaker to put them "in phase"
Its a shame that such a cool product suffers from this fundimental problem.
Would the moderators product evangelists here kindly please test this and bring it to the attention of Sony engineers please?
I would like to have a pair of SRS-XB2's that are correctly in phase.
(I suspect the rear facing bass units are the culprits, they may need to be "phase flipped"
Many thanks,
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Relax : dance ringtone, country ringtone, message tones
Link to comment
Share on other sites
1 answer to this question
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.