IC. Posted January 10 Report Share Posted January 10 Hello everyone, I'm here for the first time so I apologize if I'm using the forum incorrectly, I know it's a Sony forum, but it's the only Minidisc-related forum I could find that isn't on reddit. I've recently gotten a used JVC UX-A70MDR mini system, as it turned out the MD and CD aren't really functioning properly. At this point I have a lot of experience repairing electronics, I adore playing around with old hi-fi equipment, so I'm not really a beginner to this, but the problem here seems so stupidly simple yet so hard to diagnose that I've decided to try asking for help/advice. The problem: The mechanism is unable to detect whether a disc is present or not, after it has been already correctly loaded with the slot-loading mechanism which operates completely fine. So, when it loads the disc, it just ejects it back out after a few seconds. However, if I place the mechanism vertically on its left side, it somehow detects a loaded disc with almost 100% success rate. It spins it up, reads the TOC, and starts playing the audio just fine. Even if I place the mechanism back on its bottom in its correct horizontal orientation, it continues playing just fine without a single interruption. Playback works fully as intended. Skipping tracks and everything works just like it should. But when I stop the playback (via the stop button or by switching to another audio source), the disc spins down. When trying to play the loaded disc again, it does not spin up, the laser/magnet head assembly only moves a little forward and back, and the mini system's interface goes back to the track listing instead of playing the disc. So I am almost fully certain that the problem is with the detection of presence of a disc in the loaded position. If I rotate the mechanism to the side again when it tries to "detect" the presence of a loaded disc when wanting to play an already loaded disc, it once again spins up just fine and starts playing, which continues without any problem after placing the mechanism back on its bottom. The service manual for this device is available online (I won't post links or pictures due to potential copyright issues), although it didn't help me much. There are apparently some switches under the "cam gear", but I don't think those are responsible for anything besides the slot-loading mechanism. I am honestly not sure if this "detection" of the disc is done by some physical switch, or if it's being done by the laser. But I'm leaning towards it being an issue with the laser, which would be weird since it works completely fine after it detects a disc, but at this point it seems the most logical that the detection of the disc is done by the laser, since I know that's how common CD readers detect the presence of a disc, and I can't locate any physical switch that would be responsible for that. I'd appreciate if any of you Minidisc fans here have any idea, advice, or experience with an issue like this. However, I also fully understand that you probably don't have the time to look through a random service manual for some person on the Internet that you've never met before, just to see if you find anything they missed or didn't understand. Even if no one responds, at least some others with the same model might find this thread in the future and see that I had this issue and behavior. If it's needed, I can take some photos of the mechanism and upload them here. I'm not sure if I'm allowed to post attachments as a new user. Thank you! TL;DR summary: JVC slot loading MD drive fails to detect the presence of a disc in the loaded position, which is being done after loading the disc but also when wanting to play it again after the disc has been stopped. If I rotate the mechanism onto its side, the disc detection somehow works just fine, and after the disc spins up, the entire mechanism continues to work just fine even after placing it back on its bottom. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Syrius Posted January 10 Report Share Posted January 10 Having watched a repair video by a Youtuber, I can almost 100% assure you the detection is done by a micro-switch or some other physical sensor in the unit that gets pressed down when an MD is loaded. This is the video in question, probably won't help you much, but it's the best reference I got: Good luck. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
IC. Posted January 10 Author Report Share Posted January 10 I've seen that video a while in the past, but I will give it another watch once I return from work. Not sure if this will help me at all with this specific mechanism, though. I've tried really hard to locate a physical switch that could be responsible for the detection, both by disassembling the mechanism and studying the service manual, but found nothing. If it's a physical switch, it'd also be weird that the controller only checks its state once before reading the disc. Trivia: Sony MDS-JE510 is a device I own too, but mine thankfully doesn't have this infamous issue of these Sony models, so I never even had to take it apart. Thanks for the suggestion. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BearBoy Posted January 10 Report Share Posted January 10 Hi @IC.. Welcome to the forum! I'm not familiar with your JVC unit but does the loading mechanism use a belt? I've had an issue with Sony decks ejecting discs after a few seconds that's been solved by replacing the belt with a new one Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BearBoy Posted January 10 Report Share Posted January 10 Oh, and don't worry about posting about non-Sony kit. Despite the name, the forum's good for all things MiniDisc 🙂 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
IC. Posted January 10 Author Report Share Posted January 10 Hi, yes, the loading mechanism does have a tiny belt for the motor, and I initially suspected the loading mechanism to be the issue, but the belt and auto-loading mechanism are both completely fine. It pulls the disc in forward and down completely fine to the end. I also have been applying a small DC voltage to the motor directly while I have the mechanism disassembled and outside of the unit, it works completely fine without any resistance. I'm fairly sure it's not the loading mechanism, since when I do the trick with placing the drive on its side in order for it to detect and play the disc, but then stop the playback which makes the disc stop spinning, and then try to play the already loaded disc again, it fails to detect and spin up the disc unless I do the trick again. The loading mechanism does not move at all in the meantime, the disc stays in the fully loaded position. This might really be a one of a kind of an issue, since I haven't been able to find anything about specifically such an issue online, when I was searching before posting on this forum. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
sfbp Posted January 13 Report Share Posted January 13 Having taken lots of these MD drives apart, I would make a guess that when reassembling there was a spring not quite right. The behaviour of it working when on one side but not in normal orientation is consistent with the weight (of something including the MD itself) being enough to do what the spring was doing. That, or something needs a tweak until things are aligned. Particularly easy to do if you got a disk in the unit locked in record mode and had to use "brute force" to get it out (been there, done that). Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BearBoy Posted Tuesday at 11:42 AM Report Share Posted Tuesday at 11:42 AM Did you manage to make any progress with identifying the issue @IC.? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
IC. Posted Tuesday at 12:04 PM Author Report Share Posted Tuesday at 12:04 PM Hi, thanks for asking. Unfortunately, there's still no progress, it still acts in the same way. It works completely fine under the condition that I momentarily rotate the mechanism onto its left side in the moment just before spinning up the disc. I had the idea that the problem might in fact be with a physical microswitch, specifically the switch for detecting the home position of the laser assembly, in which case it would make sense that gravity helps it get pressed better when the mechanism is on its left side. But adding some padding and using a contact cleaner on that switch has not changed the behaviour at all. On 1/13/2025 at 4:28 PM, sfbp said: Having taken lots of these MD drives apart, I would make a guess that when reassembling there was a spring not quite right. The behaviour of it working when on one side but not in normal orientation is consistent with the weight (of something including the MD itself) being enough to do what the spring was doing. That, or something needs a tweak until things are aligned. Particularly easy to do if you got a disk in the unit locked in record mode and had to use "brute force" to get it out (been there, done that). I may have to look deeper inside the mechanism again to see if there are any potentially problematic springs, but all that I see at the moment seem to be just fine. There was no brute force needed for anything, I got the machine without a disc inside and behaving in the same way before I even started disassembling it. A friend might help me diagnose whether this is a laser issue, but I am not completely sure when and if. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
sfbp Posted Tuesday at 03:57 PM Report Share Posted Tuesday at 03:57 PM It won't be a laser issue. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.